The Lookout by Gardener's Cottage offers a dining experience that emphasizes seasonal Scottish produce, complemented by breathtaking views of Edinburgh. The quality of ingredients and presentation is commendable, though some diners may find the portion sizes modest. The main course, while featuring excellent protein and potato, could benefit from more substantial servings. Service is attentive and accommodating, particularly with dietary restrictions, and the location atop Castle Hill provides a stunning backdrop, especially at sunset. The set menu, highlighted by dishes like venison and scallops, is well-executed, making it a fitting choice for a romantic date or a special occasion. While the price is justified, a slight increase in portion size would enhance the overall experience. Overall, The Lookout delivers a unique and memorable dining experience in Edinburgh.

The Lookout by Gardener's Cottage

Description